Sunday, September 13, 2020

Confessions of an Automationeer, Part 95: When CSR Goes Wrong

Confessions of an Automationeer, Part 95: When CSR Goes Wrong

Among the many competitions that have been held on the Automation forums, CSR has been the flagship for almost five full years now, primarily because everything about it has generally maintained a very high standard in that time. However, this does not mean that it has never had any low points at all; in fact, there have been quite a few. So, without further ado, here are my top three picks for CSR rounds gone wrong (for one or more reasons), in no particular order.
  • CSR 115 - The premise for this one was actually very sound, but many of the entries were disqualified for either being built in an open beta build of Automation, and thereby incompatible (at a time when use of the most recent stable build was mandatory) or simply not meeting the eligibility requirements. Even then, many users continued to complain on the forums, not just once, but several times, forcing moderators to lock the thread shortly after the winner had been announced. Thankfully, this has yet to happen in any future CSR at the time of writing.
  • CSR 64 - This round, the fourth to be held using the UE4 version of Automation, marked the exact point where CSR hit rock bottom. Not only was the rule set too vague, the backstory was also far too confusing, thereby putting off many potential entrants. In fact, only thirteen users chose to take the plunge, and few of those found it to be worth their time and effort. Worse yet, the reviews were sub-par, and the host seemed to have lost interest by the time it was all over - to the point that, after having hosted several CSR rounds in quick succession, he abstained from hosting temporarily.
  • CSR 59 - Much like CSR 64, this one also had a vague rule set, but the scoring criteria were determined by a set of equations that made them even more obtuse and thereby unconvincing. It was primarily for this reason that this round had the lowest turnout of any CSR ever, at just eight entrants in total.
Fortunately, in all of these cases, the rounds immediately after these three proved to be much better overall. In the case of CSR 64, the custodians of the series even took some more drastic action to stop (or at least reduce the probability of) such a farcical result from ever happening again, along with requiring every future CSR round to have its own dedicated thread - and it has worked a treat. Nearly every CSR round from the 65th one onwards has had a strong turnout, although it was not until a few months ago that it reached what is currently its zenith. Then again, considering how much better CSR has become overall over the past few months, that may not be the case for much longer.

Friday, September 11, 2020

Confessions of an Automationeer, Part 94: The Importance of Test Mules

Confessions of an Automationeer, Part 94: The Importance of Test Mules

Let's face it, there have been many cars entered in various Automation forum competitions over the years that looked promising on paper, but were ultimately undone by poor engineering choices. To lessen the chances of this happening, it pays to create a developmental mock-up of your vehicle, commonly referred to as a mule, as real-life car companies do when developing a new vehicle. It is generally meant to be representative of the final product not in terms of exterior design, but in mechanical specifications. As such, mules tend to either have no exterior fixtures at all, or a very basic appearance - one that is seldom representative of the final product.

With an engineering test mule, it's the trim choices, chassis options, and engine (all of which affect stats such as drivability, sportiness, comfort, prestige, safety, etc.) that matter most. Unlike styling, all three of these areas are meant to be as similar to those of the finished product as possible. Therefore, it is in these areas that the definitive car's specifications are finalized. For example, here are some screenshots of a test build I made of a mid-1970s American mid-sized sedan, in its unfinished state as an engineering mule with paint and wheels (but not fixtures) fitted.



Above, from top: Chassis and body choice for a test mule of a mid-1970s American sedan, with body style, morphs, exterior colors and wheel shape finalized, but no fixtures added to the body.

Having chosen the chassis options, along with the body shape and style, I then set about finalizing the engineering. The engine was typical of the era - a pushrod V8 strangled by a catalytic converter and regular unleaded petrol, yet still capable of developing 150 horsepower, which I deemed to be sufficient for a car of this size and type.






Above, from top: Screenshots showing an overview of the engine I chose to fit to my test mule.

Finally, here are some screenshots of each individual trim tab, showing more trim and engineering options for my test mule.








Above, from top: A series of screenshots showing various aspects of my test mule's engineering and trim.

The resulting car felt like a typical land barge of the era, albeit smaller - soft in the corners, and not very fast, but as comfortable as any separate-chassis, leaf-sprung American iron could get for its size, which pleased me very much indeed. In short, if you are unsure as to the engineering approach you want to take for a particular car, it is highly recommended to create some test mules first. Only when you are satisfied with the stats for one of them should you then develop it further.

Thursday, September 10, 2020

Confessions of an Automationeer, Part 93: Hampton Leads The Charge

Confessions of an Automationeer, Part 93: Hampton Leads The Charge

As Generations II reaches its sixth round, it would be remiss to recap what happened in the previous one, as well as what came immediately afterwards. I was reluctant to write this post initially, but recent events made me reconsider. Some of the changes made to the Hampton Motor Group range from 1977 to 1981 include:
  • All models: From 1981, advanced automatic transmission becomes available as an option for the first time ever - by then, mechanical fuel injection is now standard across the entire range. Minor trim, equipment and mechanical changes are also implemented.
  • Harpy: Launched in 1977; GTS trim added to range in 1981, with a more powerful engine and sportier suspension and gearing.
  • Fennec: Mechanical fuel injection optional from 1977.
  • Valiant: Redesigned for 1977 with new body and independent rear suspension.
  • Ferret: As above, but powered by 4-cylinder engines only.
  • Vanguard: As above, but with three body styles (short- or long-wheelbase sedan, plus short-wheelbase coupe).
  • Nevis II: Prematurely launched with carbureted engine, then recalled and given fuel-injected engine partway through 1977.
  • Transtar: New body for 1977; engine family now shared with Fennec, Ferret and Valiant.
  • Fairlie: Completely new for 1977; built on shortened Nevis platform and powered solely by a 4-cylinder engine.






Above, from top: An assortment of new models launched or revised by Hampton from 1977 to 1981, in the aftermath of the oil crisis.

Given that fuel prices had gone through the roof in 1974, Hampton shifted their focus to comfort and economy - but they could not ignore the performance market completely, and so, in 1977 they launched their first new sports car in two decades - the Harpy. Built on the Valiant platform, it would eventually come of age in 1981 when the high-performance GTS trim was added to the range.

All in all, Chairman Toby's efforts to stay relevant were finally paying off, setting the stage for a turnaround later in the decade. That, though, has already been mostly covered earlier in this series, and as such may not be revisited for some time yet.

Saturday, August 15, 2020

Doll Maker's Diary, Part 39: A Special 28th Birthday Present

Doll Maker's Diary, Part 39: A 28th Birthday Present


In celebration of my 28th birthday, I have taken the opportunity to show some new artworks depicting the women of CRASH Chronicles celebrating the occasion. To start us off, here are the original four members dressed up to the nines, on a rooftop at night with their powers on display for all to see:


The four original women of CRASH Chronicles lighting up the sky in honor of my 28th birthday...

Next up are the four newcomers, originally part of the defunct STAR Power initiative, joining in the festivities.


...and the "reinforcements" are getting in on the act as well!

Last but not least, here are two artworks showing all eight of them together, with CRASH Commander Claire Hayes wishing me a very happy birthday in the latter:



The women of CRASH Chronicles sending out their best wishes in honor of my 28th birthday.

And to anyone in the real world viewing this blog... Thank you for all your birthday wishes!

Friday, August 14, 2020

Enhanced Versions of the Game of Life: Spicing Up the Experience

Enhanced Versions of the Game of Life: Spicing Up the Experience


Some computer game adaptations of the popular Hasbro board game The Game of Life feature an option for an "Enhanced Mode", which significantly changes the rule set compared to the default "Classic Mode" setup. Here are the changes that were made in the Enhanced Modes of each video game version of the Game of Life.

1998 Version (based on Generation II)

The most significant difference in this version of the game (which was based on Generation II) is that the Enhanced mode omits Life Tiles entirely. Instead, any player who lands on a Life Space must spin again. Number 5 is  reserved for Revenge, in which that player can choose an opponent (unless he/she has retired at Countryside Acres) to take their mini-game winnings from (or give to, in the event of a negative score in Up or Down), while number 10 is  used for an increase in the winnings multiplier by 1 - which is especially effective if that player wins a very large amount. Other numbers will either yield a small amount of money (up to $20,000 without multipliers), or start one of the following mini-games, which in this game are called "Life's Little Games":
  • Safe Cracker: You have four attempts to earn as much possible by clicking on a space; however, you can only keep the last amount you have revealed. Click the Done button if you are satisfied with the amount you have earned.
  • Up or Down: You can click on as many spaces as you want; however, in addition to there being one each of every possible denomination on the grid (from as low as $5,000, $10,000 or $25,000, to as high as $50,000, $75,000 or $100,000), there is also one each of every negative denomination. Click the Done button at any time to stop.
  • Get a Life: You have six clicks to reveal one each of the letters L, I, F and E. You will earn $100,000 if you do it in four clicks, $75,000 if you do it in five, and $50,000 if you do it in six. When you find a letter, it will appear in the top-right corner of the display.
  • Treasure Chest: The grid contains two each of the six denominations, and you can click up to six times to find a pair of matching amounts. The game ends after six clicks or if a matching pair is found.
  • Skunk Money: In this game, the grid does not contain spaces worth $75,000 or $100,000. However, it has one $50,000 space, two $20,000 spaces, six $10,000 spaces, a "Double Your Winnings" space, which doubles the amount that can potentially be earned if clicked on, and two "Skunk" spaces which would remove all previously accumulated winnings if you clicked on either of them, as well as ending the game. You can click the Done button at any time to end the game voluntarily.
  • Cannon Ball: This is similar to Treasure Chest with the major exception that you may uncover more than one matching pair, and have eight clicks to find as many of them as you can.
In addition to the mini-games listed above, the PC port of this game also includes two additional mini-games:
  • Crane Dump: There is a crane holding a ball at the top of the screen, and five slots (two marked $10,000, two marked $25,000, and one marked $50,000) at the bottom. Click on the green Drop button to drop the ball into a slot; however, no more than one ball can occupy a slot at any time. If a ball falls into an occupied slot, both balls will be lost. Clicking on the Done button will end the mini-game.
  • Trash Can: This time, the crane is stationary, and the green button now reads "Move", while the red button reads "Drop"; clicking on it will move the bucket at the bottom of the screen from left to right between each of the five slots. You will start with six balls, and will receive $50,000 for each ball that lands in the bucket, for a theoretical maximum winnings of $300,000.
In addition, Enhanced Mode in this game reintroduces "Revenge" (in which landing on a Pay Day space allows you to take money from anyone who has not retired at Countryside Acres), wedding and baby gifts ($1,000 x spin per child, and $2,000 x spin for marriage), and requires players to spin on their turn after retirement, to either gain or lose money. Countryside Acres retirees had more chances to earn money, albeit in smaller amounts; Millionaire Estates retirees, on the other hand, had more chances to lose money (and in larger amounts to boot), as well as larger positive payouts. This had the side-effect of making Countryside Acres the more viable of the two retirement options available, since the risk of losing money at Millionaire Estates was often too great.

2008 Version (based on Generation III)

In this game, career choice is handled differently in Enhanced Mode. If you choose to start a career right away, you will play a memory game in which you try to obtain as many matching pairs of regular Career Cards. If any of those have already been taken, they will be replaced with Jokers that will not add to your total; moreover, if you fail to obtain a matching pair, you will be given a random unused Career Card. On the other hand, if you choose to go to college, you get to select three College Career Cards upon graduation; these cards are then shuffled around randomly, and you then get to choose exactly one of them before resuming your turn. Finally, for players who return to school, they will have to select from up to two unused College Career Cards or their current career card.

A more significant change can be found in Share the Wealth Cards, which are no longer stockpiled, but are instead used immediately upon collection, and now have one of the following randomly chosen effects:
  • Christmas Bonus: Receive half of your current salary.
  • Give a Loan: Give a loan (worth $20,000 + $1,000 initial interest) to any other player.
  • Take a Loan Off: Return a $20,000 loan (including interest) to the bank.
  • Shared Memories: Collect a Life Tile from any other player.
  • Lucky Spin: Starts a Spin to Win in which you can select four numbers while all other players must choose only one. A side effect of this is that in a normal Spin to Win, all players can only select one number each (except for the Computer Designer, which can select two).
  • House Exchange: Trade your Starter Home/House with any other player.
  • Job Exchange: As above but you trade Career Cards with another player.
In addition, loans now come with simple interest of $1,000 per loan, and after taking out loans, your debt will increase by $1,000 multiplied by the number of outstanding loans - there is no compound interest. You must therefore pay off your debt as soon as possible in Enhanced Mode.

Pay Raises are handled differently as well: reaching a Pay Raise space triggers the Pay Raise game, in which you are presented with 12 cards laid out in a 3x4 grid. Each card contains a cash amount ranging from $1,000 to $9,000 in $1,000 increments, and there are also two $8,000 and three $9,000 cards on the grid. You can click as many times as you want to determine the size of your Pay Raise; however, if you exceed $15,000, you will not receive a Pay Raise at all. Please note that all of these values are doubled for anyone with the Athlete career. Also, a player with the Entertainer career will be able to play the Pay Raise game if two identical numbers greater than 7 (i.e. 8, 9 or 10) are spun on two consecutive turns, as stated below.

Starter Homes are bought in the same way as College Careers are chosen. Buying a better home is a more complicated process though. Any player who chooses to do so must select two House Cards, and these, along with that player's existing Starter Home card, are shuffled around. If a House Card is selected, the Starter Home must be sold. Also, at the end of the game, a player must sell their Starter Home or House upon retirement. In general, low numbers yield the least amount of cash, and high numbers provide the largest profits relative to a house's initial purchase price.

Lawsuits are also handled differently in a mini-game called the Trial Game. After selecting an opponent, both players are shown a picture, and have 25 seconds each to memorize it fully. The plaintiff (i.e. the player who landed on a Lawsuit space on this turn) then has 25 seconds (starting from when the Go button at the top-left corner is clicked on) to assemble a section of the picture on a 4x3 grid, after which the defendant has 20 seconds (ditto) to do the same. At the end of the Trial Game, the player who assembled more of their picture in the time allotted wins; the greater the margin of victory, the more money they will collect from their opponent. However, in the event of a draw, neither player will gain or lose any money at all. Finally, any player with the Lawyer career will have an advantage in every Trial Game in which they are involved.

Most Pay and Collect spaces have also been modified; instead of fixed amounts, these spaces will add or subtract different sums of cash depending on which matching pair of values a player discovers first during a Scratch Game. However, all Taxes Due spaces and all Pay Spaces whose values depend on the number of children a player has will remain unaffected, as are the Pension and Tax Refund spaces.

Another feature reinstated from previous versions of the Game of Life is the set of special abilities unique to each career. They are as follows:
  • Salesperson: Receive a 10% cut of the purchase price of any house bought by any other player.
  • Hair Stylist: Spin for gifts whenever any other player has children, with values determined in the same way as wedding gifts (no gifts for numbers 1-4, $5,000 for numbers 5-7, and $10,000 for numbers 8-10).
  • Mechanic: Collect $10,000 from any opponents involved in an overtaking move.
  • Police Officer: Collect $5,000 from anyone who spins a 10. This special ability is also the only one present in the standard rule set.
  • Entertainer: Play the Pay Raise game if two identical numbers greater than 7 are spun on consecutive turns.
  • Athlete: All cash values and limits in the Pay Raise game are doubled.
  • Teacher: You no longer have to pay tuition fees of any kind (including the $50,000 required to return to school), either for yourself or your children.
  • Computer Designer: Receive an additional number to select in Spin to Win.
  • Accountant: Cannot pay taxes or receive a tax refund, but can collect $5,000 in tax preparation fees when another player pays taxes.
  • Veterinarian: Receive a Life Tile upon reaching a Pay Raise space.
  • Lawyer: Gain more money and lose less money from Lawsuits, and collect $10,000 from anyone who wins a Lawsuit.
  • Doctor: You no longer have to pay for medical expenses, and can collect those of others.
On balance, it seems that among all the careers, the Athlete has the most useful special ability of all, since any player with that career has the potential to gain a Pay Raise of $20,000 or more multiple times. In addition, the Lawyer tends to be the best College Career to have in most circumstances, since having it makes lawsuits easier to manage (and win) than with any other career. As such, both of these careers are now the most prized of all in the Enhanced Play rule set.

2014 Version (Generation IV)

This version still has mini-games, but they have completely replaced the redesigned Spin to Win from the source material, and there are fewer of them to boot. They are as follows:
  • Statues: Each player starts at the edge of the circle and must work their way towards the center by clicking or tapping. However, for each player, there is a guard near the center, and it may turn to face them occasionally. If a guard catches a player on the move, that player will be sent back to the edge of the circle. The winner is the player who advances farthest within the time limit or is the first to reach the center, thereby earning 100,000 points in the latter.
  • Grab The Cash: Each player takes one side of the circle, and aims to collect as many bank notes as possible by dragging their mover left and right while also avoiding bank loans (which have a 10,000 point penalty each). Notes in this game can be worth 1,000, 5,000, 10,000, 20,000, or 50,000; however, each player's score is rounded to the nearest 10,000 points. The player who earns the most points when the time limit is reached wins.
Unlike in earlier versions, these mini-games are the only features that are unique to the "Enhanced Mode" in this version of the Game of Life.

In my view, the lack of mini-games compared to earlier versions actually makes the newest version of the Game of Life less unpredictable than it needs to be, especially when playing against AI opponents - I often find it all too easy to win the mini-games against them. That said, without the mini-games, I would have had to mark this version of the Game of Life even further down the rankings (specifically, in last place) a few months ago.

In short, whenever a computer game adaptation of the Game of Life comes out, an Enhanced Mode incorporating significant rule changes is not only expected, it's required. Done right, it can make the game as fun to play as, if not more so than, the standard (Classic) rule set; done wrong, it will seem like it's not different enough from the default rules. Even so, a bare-bones Enhanced Mode in any version of the Game of Life is better than not having one at all.

Tuesday, July 28, 2020

Confessions of an Automationeer, Part 92: Hampton Muscles In

Confessions of an Automationeer, Part 92: Hampton Muscles In

1966: Hampton's First Muscle Car Debuts
1966 marked a major milestone for the Hampton Motor Group - the Warwickshire-based company took the lucrative American market by storm with its first muscle car, the Valiant V8 5.0. The regular Valiant wasn't a bad car - in fact, it was quite decent, but this high-performance flagship was making all the headlines that year, thanks to its superb all-around performance. Not even the fact that it was more expensive than its rivals could stop it from being voted the best muscle car by the fictional Motor Review World magazine at the time of its launch.


Left to right: Some of the cars offered by the Hampton Motor Group in 1966 - Ferret II 1.8 (far left), Valiant II Prime (left), Valiant II V8 5.0 (right), and Transtar 2.0 van (far right).

The smaller Ferret II was more divisive, though; it was more comfortable than other competitors in its class, and offered competitive economy and practicality, but at the expense of inferior reliability and being more expensive to buy and run than most of its counterparts. Realizing this, Hampton began drawing up a second compact model line that would better suited to the economy car role (which would turn out to be the Fennec), while also planning to enlarge the Ferret for the next few generations and shift it upmarket.

Meanwhile, in the utility sector, their refreshed Transtar remained a popular choice among fleets seeking vans to use for hauling cargo. It was as cheap to buy as ever, and had a high load capacity. It was not as capable of off-roading as some of its rivals, though, but this was not much of a problem given that Transtars were primarily designed for (and used on) paved roads.


Revised versions of the Peregrine (above) and Shrike (below) were also new to the Hampton range for 1966.



As for its sports cars, the Peregrine received the Valiant's V8, but in a slightly more aggressive state of tune, while the smaller Shrike received an enlarged and more powerful engine displacing 2.2 litres. The extra power was decidedly welcome in both models, and kept them relevant even into the next decade.

Speaking of which, founder and CEO Toby Hampton announced in the fall of 1966 that the rest of Hampton's core range would be updated by 1972 to keep them competitive. As part of that plan, the Valiant II would receive more powerful engines, as would the new Vanguard II (which was scheduled for launch in 1969); the latter would also be the first Hampton to use hydropneumatic suspension, with a new semi-trailing arm rear end providing improved comfort over its predecessor's coil-sprung live rear axle.

1972: Hampton Powers Up Again
The Vanguard II was initially offered with six- and eight-cylinder engines at launch; however, from 1972, only the V8-powered versions remained, with the top 5.0-litre trim now endowed with 200 horsepower. Unlike its predecessor, it was also available as a two-door coupe as well as a four-door sedan. Also in 1972, the Vanguard range received more advanced safety equipment commensurate with its positioning as the company's flagship. As with all other Hampton models, US-spec examples were fitted with rear side marker lights and front parking lights, while passenger's side mirrors were now standard across the board. In addition, an 8-track player was also offered as standard equipment for the first time.

As for the Valiant II, the high-performance Sprint trim could now be upgraded to a SuperSprint package, which finally added the high-lift camshaft, high-flow intake and long-tube headers that had been standard on the Peregrine V8 for so long. With 270 net horsepower, this was the most powerful version of Hampton's original overhead-valve V8. Production was cut short after the first oil crisis, but with all the performance improvements, it was a great way to go out. Lesser six-cylinder models also received engine tweaks that boosted their performance and efficiency. However, all trims of the Valiant II would also receive safety upgrades as regulations tightened during the 1970s, along with the addition of extra standard equipment.


Some of the new models introduced by Hampton in 1972, from left to right: Valiant II 3.5 Prime, Valiant 5.0 V8 Supersprint, and Vanguard II V8 5.0. 

Postscript
Given that the Ferret was proving to be somewhat more expensive and less reliable than anticipated, but still a competitive choice due to its comfort and economy, Hampton also chose to develop a second compact car platform, one that would underpin a more affordable entry-level offering as the Ferret slowly moved upmarket. This was, in fact, their first-ever transverse-engined, front-wheel-drive car, and it would ultimately be called the Fennec when it debuted in 1974. That model line would go on to have a long and successful production life, and would even receive a facelift in 1985, before being replaced by an all-new Fennec in the early 1990s as part of a company-wide model range refresh - but that is a story for another post.

Tuesday, July 21, 2020

Game of Life Generations, Ranked: Which One is the Best of them All in my Opinion?

Game of Life Generations, Ranked: Which One is the Best of them All in my Opinion?


As you may already have known by now, Hasbro's Game of Life - its second most recognizable board game after Monopoly - has been around for 60 years now, having been introduced in 1960, and is still going strong in 2020. In that time, it has evolved through four distinct generations, with the first two of those receiving a redesign partway through their lifespans. So which one is the best, according to my humble opinion? To determine a definitive ranking, I will consider a variety of factors, such as difficulty, balance, and most importantly of all, fun factor. In addition, I won't treat redesigns of the same generation separately, nor will I include any of the spin-offs such as the Adventure, Fame and Twists & Turns Editions due to their different rule sets. So here they are, from worst to best - relatively speaking, since there has never been a bad version of the Game of Life, only good ones.

4th: Generation 1 (1960-1989) - Strong Start Squandered By An Overstayed Welcome
Some of you are wondering why the original version of Hasbro's Game of Life isn't the best. Part of this is due to relative unfamiliarity among younger fans, including myself, but also because it was less balanced gameplay-wise than any of its successors - something that its original creator, Milton Bradley, could not have foreseen. For example, it was possible to be eliminated from the game altogether if you failed to spin the number you had bet on after attempting to become a Millionaire Tycoon upon landing on the Day of Reckoning space (which led straight to the Poor Farm) - not an ideal way to finish a game. Besides, anyone who actually becomes a Millionaire Tycoon will win the game, thereby preventing others from retiring normally unless they have already done so - and where's the fun in that?

On the other hand, the original Game of Life introduced all the basic principles of the game we are familiar with, and many of its features (such as Share the Wealth Cards and Lucky Day, the latter being known as Spin To Win in recent years) would be present in at least one subsequent edition of the game. Moreover, Stock certificates were depicted more realistically than in any subsequent version of the game: some Collect Spaces could only affect players who had already purchased stocks, while on the other hand, there were also Pay Spaces that, if landed on, would cause any stock owner to lose money. Finally, it is the only version to support eight players instead of six or four, as in later versions, and it was the longest-lived one as well, with a total lifespan of 30 years - although for some reason, this was a much longer run than anticipated, which meant that it almost became stale by the late 1980s, thereby necessitating a redesign (more on which later).

3rd: Generation IV (since 2013) - A Decent Idea Compromised By Oversimplification
The latest version of the Game of Life isn't the greatest either, but at least it's not the worst. Unlike all previous versions, it only supports four players, which would've been fine if Hasbro kept some of the more interesting features found in earlier editions. But they didn't, and so this version falls short on fun factor compared to its predecessors. In particular, players now compete not for money, but for points. At least the Action Cards in this version are well worth collecting (100,000 points each), and the game now incentivizes early retirements by giving larger cash bonuses to players who reach the end of the board and retire before their opponents do.

Giving each career an investment number from the get-go (as opposed to having to buy one) seems odd to me, though, especially since you can now use it to collect money from opponents, not just the bank. And to confuse matters further, some video game adaptations of this version also change the amount of money awarded through careers' investment numbers, making some of them needlessly overpowered - an issue that is sadly not unique to this version of the Game of Life, and especially undesirable here.

In fairness, the decision to downsize the game to four players makes sense given that many recent spin-offs of the Game of Life also support four players each. In my opinion, those off-shoots benefit greatly from the faster pace that ensues from having to support only four players. However, in the regular Game of Life, it only serves to create a game that I consider to be too short compared to what it once was. Finally, the fact that house purchases are now optional (rather than mandatory), and even then can only be done upon landing on a House space (of which there are now several, has traditionalists up in arms, to say the least. All things considered, this still isn't the worst version of the Game of Life to have been released, but it's a long way from the best. Speaking of which, the next entry is a much stronger contender for that title.

2nd: Generation III (2007-2013) - Intensity that was Too Good to Last
Picking a winner proved to be more difficult than I had realized, so I'll start with the merits of Generation III. Firstly, it was the first version of the Game of Life not to be significantly redesigned in any way during its production run, since much of it was fundamentally right from the outset. It also reintroduced Spin to Win (formerly known as Lucky Day), wedding and baby gifts, and Share the Wealth Cards after a long absence, while also discarding insurance policies due to the fact that they had lost much of their effectiveness in Generation II. Moreover, it introduced us to the all-new Lawsuit mechanic, which allowed you to take money directly from another player ($100,000) unless they had an Exemption Card, in which case they had to hand that card in to the bank instead.

This version of the Game of Life also spawned more video game adaptations than any other, which explains my familiarity with it. Returning to the subject of gameplay, it made house purchases more manageable than previously, since you could no longer make a loss upon selling a house. Better still, stock cards, which were now referred to as Long-Term Investments, now cost much less to purchase; as such, buying them was now more worthwhile than ever before, especially in the early stages of the game. Life Tile values had already been decreased midway through the previous version's life cycle, but they were still useful here. Finally, Generation III turned out to be the last version of the Game of Life ever to support up to six players, which I feel is the ideal maximum for this sort of game.

So why isn't it my all-time favorite version of the Game of Life? Blame it on balance and unpredictability, or in this case, the relative lack of either at times. Some of this stems from the fact that this was the first version of the game in which College Careers were overpowered (especially the highest-paying ones), for three reasons: First, they tended to pay out more over the course of a game (at least initially) than most regular careers. Second, it was quite easy to obtain higher-paying College Careers early on, especially with the newly introduced mechanic of returning to school to either swap your current career with any unused College Career, or earn two Pay Raises worth $10,000. Speaking of which, they're the third reason why this game is not as unpredictable as I'd hoped, since there are just four careers which don't have a maximum salary limit.

There are other areas where the game lacks balance. For example, a player who loses too much money from lawsuits will struggle to get back into the game, and losing your job after passing the Return to School space is more detrimental than if it occurs earlier, since there is no way to regain your previous job. Most egregiously of all, winning $500,000 in Spin to Win can potentially put a player very far out of reach of any opponent, especially if that player manages to do so multiple times - yet another reason why this version of the game is not always as unpredictable as its predecessor, and it may even (at least partially) explain why this version of the Game of Life had such a short print run of just six years.

Even so, I consider this to be among the most enjoyable versions of the Game of Life ever to be released. In particular, with four or more players, it becomes very intense, especially in the later stages of a game. And the fact that this is the only version since the original to feature Share the Wealth Cards also adds a strategic element not seen since the original. Nevertheless, it must still finish second in my order behind its predecessor - and I am about to show you why.

1st: Generation II (1991-2006) - The Best Version to Date... But Only Just
Surprised that this version of the Game of Life is at the top of this list? So am I. It may be due to the fact that, for the first fifteen years of my life, the second edition of the Game of Life was the only one I ever knew about, and therefore the first one I ever bought; I played it quite often in my youth. However, it's not the only reason why it sits atop my list. It also represented a major turning point in the history of the Game of Life, where it attempted to become more relevant with the times - and succeeded. This is borne out in its longevity - it was in print for a total of fifteen years, which, while only half as long as its predecessor, is still a very long time, and twice as long as the lifespans (to date) of both the third and fourth generations combined.

What else can possibly explain why the second edition of the Game of Life is somehow still my favorite even after all these years? I suspect it comes down to the fact that, unlike any other version of the Game of Life, each career was compatible with multiple salary values instead of just one; in fact, prior to the 2002 redesign, any career could be combined with any salary value. Also, you were far less likely to lose your job (and salary) than in Generation III, and in addition to that, had two chances to change your career (and salary) voluntarily instead of just one, and at a lower price to boot ($20,000 instead of $50,000).

Unlike its immediate predecessor, Generation II also lacked any instant loss or win conditions, which I believed ruined the fun if any of them were met. Instead, everyone would be guaranteed to retire at the end of the game. Speaking of which, this was the first version of the Game of Life to refer to the two retirement options as Countryside Acres or Millionaire Estates - a trait shared with all later versions.

Choosing either option over the other was also more likely to decide the outcome of a game than in any subsequent version of the Game of Life. Countryside Acres retirees would receive a Life Tile (taking from another player if necessary, unless there was nobody to take it from) and could not have their Life Tiles taken from them, but could not receive the stash of four Life Tiles at Millionaire Estates. Millionaire Estates retirees, on the other hand, could have their Life Tiles taken from them if the draw pile ran out, but they would receive four Life Tiles if they were the wealthiest player to retire there. This could lead to some unexpected outcomes, especially before the 2002 redesign which we will discuss later.

In addition, although this version had only nine Career Cards in all, only two of them required a college degree, whereas exactly half of the 12 Career Cards in Generation III had this requirement. On top of that, you could choose from one of three each of Career and Salary Cards if you earned a college degree at the start of the game. Moreover, this was the first version to feature Life Tiles, which were originally worth between $50,000 to $250,000 in increments of $50,000, thereby providing players with a means of gaining yet more money if they had little cash on hand upon retirement. All this led to a level of overall unpredictability, intensity and competitiveness more often seen than in any other version of the Game of Life - one that I fear may never be seen again.

In fact, even after the 2002 redesign (the 40th Anniversary re-issue was nothing more than an aesthetic makeover) which sorted salary cards into one of four color groups (red, yellow, green or blue), restricted every Career card to a salary belonging to either of two of those groups, and even reduced the value of all Life Tiles five-fold (to between $10,000 and $50,000, in $10,000 increments), it was still quite possible to have a close, exciting game - if anything it was even more likely than before the redesign. Another reason for this competitiveness is that unlike in other versions, there were several spaces where you could trade your Salary Card with one belonging to another player, and if your salary was low relative to your opponent's, it would leave you in a strong position while at the same time also putting your opponent at a disadvantage. However, this meant that the best salary to have was often the second-highest-paying one among all players - the player(s) with the highest-paying one would often be the target of salary trades as a result.

As icing on the cake, this was the first version of the Game of Life to receive a computer game adaptation while it was still in print - something to be expected in modern times, but totally out of the question with its predecessor due to the absence of the technology required for such a project. Crucially, though, the virtual board game version added extra modes and features that the source material did not have, thereby improving the fun factor. This trend would continue in all subsequent video game adaptations of the Game of Life, which explains their popularity, especially among casual gamers. There was even a mobile phone game based on the original release of this version in the mid-2000s, and while it had a different set of mini-games, it too proved to be as enjoyable as expected.

It's not perfect, though. For starters, players originally did not sell their houses upon retirement, making the cheaper options more attractive (hence my preference for a house rule requiring every house to be sold for 50% more than its original price at the end of the game). Even though the first major redesign finally added resale values for houses (and a space where you could sell your current house mid-game in place of a Life Tile space), they were all dependent on the number(s) you could have spun when you attempted to sell them, and this meant that, as before, some houses were still less worthwhile to purchase than others.

Another problem with this version is that although some careers are more lucrative than others, it's arguably more pronounced here than it was before or since. For example, the Accountant is especially coveted since anyone with that career not only collects taxes from others, but doesn't have to pay them in return. On the other hand, the Police Officer is the least prized career, despite its ability to collect $5,000 ($10,000 after the redesign) from any player who spins a 10; it has only one space associated with it, and even that one yields the officer only $15,000 when someone with another career lands on it. To counter this, all other non-College Careers received special abilities in the 2002 redesign. Even so, the problem of different levels of lucrativity remained, and thus all career-specific abilities were omitted altogether from all future installments.

As a side note, in this version of the Game of Life, Stock Cards were less useful than they (or their equivalents) were in other versions; although they yielded $10,000 when anyone spun their number after someone bought them, each one cost $50,000 to purchase. To mitigate this shortcoming, Hasbro added a space which would yield a free Stock Card if landed on (unless every Stock Card was already in use), along with a pair of spaces that would cost you one Stock Card if landed on, to balance this out.

Nevertheless, for all its faults, Generation II still remains my favorite version of the Game of Life - and deservedly so, but only by a whisker.

Conclusion
Having played every version of the Game of Life to date, I have learned that the best ones stand out mainly for a few things: well-judged gameplay balance, decent length (but obviously not as long as Monopoly, which Hasbro also publishes), and enough fun factor to keep you interested for hours on end. The second and third generations of the Game of Life, more than any other before or since, had these qualities in spades, and as such these versions remain firm favorites of mine to this day. Hopefully, Hasbro can bring back these elements for future versions of the Game of Life and restore the fun factor that made earlier versions so great in the eyes of players and fans.